When we hear
bacteria, our first reaction is usually to grab the hand sanitizer. So it is surprising to learn that a protein
found in some bacteria has become one of the most widely used ways to
manipulate DNA. This protein, CRISPR, is
used by bacteria to cut up viral DNA before it can be used to make more viruses. Scientists have manipulated the protein to
have even more functions, as summarized in Schaeffer’s and Nakata’s article.
To understand the versatility
and potential CRISPR possess, one must first have an understanding of how our
genetics are stored in DNA, and how our DNA results in who we are. DNA is a like a zipped up zipper, with each
tooth having its own identity, marked as a letter. The four possible letters are A, T, C, and
G. This code can be converted into
another molecule, RNA, which is only 1 side of the zipper. This RNA is used as a template by the cell to
make proteins, which are responsible for almost every function of the
cell. This means that by manipulating
the DNA of the organism, we can manipulate how it functions.
![]() |
View full image here |
CRISPR, with the
help of Cas9 that helps speed-up the CRISPR’s performance, is capable of making
breaks in the DNA, like cutting in between two zipper teeth. It does this by using RNA as a guide, so
scientists can isolate the RNA for a specific protein, then find the specific
piece of DNA that corresponds to that protein called a gene. The code can be determined for that gene, so
it can be compared to other sources of the same gene. This can give insight into why a person may
have a condition, or have the potential to give insight into evolution. Since CRISPR is capable of making these cuts,
it could be used to remove DNA, or new DNA could be introduced. This means we would potentially manipulate
proteins produced, and thus fix some genetic problems. Since an organism is composed of millions of
cells, this would have to occur early in development, which adds another
barrier to potentially great advances.
There are also
other limitations to CRISPR, but methods are being developed to limit
these. One problem is CRISPR cutting in
places that are not desired. To help fix
this, a modified Cas9 has been developed that results in 50-1000 fold less
unwanted cuts as opposed to the old system.
This means that the desired DNA manipulation is much more likely to
occur without problems. While we are not
able to completely manipulate a human yet, we have determined the whole code of
human DNA, called a genome, so we are well on our way to being able to detect
and treat diseases or problems that affect us.
CRISPR and Cas9 have even been manipulated
for use beyond DNA alteration. A
“reprogramed” CRISPR/Cas9 system has been developed that recognizes RNA instead
of DNA, allowing for the detection, analysis, and alteration of RNA. In
addition, Cas9 itself has even been manipulated. As I mentioned before, RNA is derived from
DNA, but RNA production is a more complex process. Imagine part of the teeth of the zipper are a
specific code, called a promoter, where the zipper can attach, but not to both
teeth sides at one. Then the zipper
moves down the teeth, making another set of teeth that is free from the
template set it is making it from. This
is the RNA, and the zipper is a protein called RNA polymerase. Often times the RNA polymerase needs help
binding to the promoter, so other proteins bind there first which makes it
easier for the RNA polymerase to bind, like using a set of tools to attach the zipper. This explanation is given as manipulated Cas9
have been used to act like these tools, engaging the creation of certain RNA that
scientists can manipulate. They have
also been able to bind manipulated Cas9 to promotor regions that cause little
to no RNA to be produced. This means we
have the ability to potentially alter a persons expressed traits by turning off
and on certain genes. The benefit to
this is it could be used much more easily than attempting to alter the DNA
itself.
The potential applications of CRISPR and
Cas9 seem limitless, but one must remember that functionality in certain
situations does not mean universality. While
we will likely reach a level where we will be able to alter genomes to create
traits that we desire, it raises many issues beyond the realm of science. One begins to question if it is fair that we
could potentially create intelligent, athletic, and/or disease free humans for
a certain cost. There is also the threat
of low genetic diversity, as if these methods are made to produce better crops
there is the potential a new disease could wipe them all out as they are
basically the same organism genetically.
Given the advances in the field, the coming years will be full of
discoveries, and it will be interesting to see how these concerns turn out.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteYou bring up an interesting point with CRISPR-Cas9 and genetic engineering of humans. In genetic engineering, there are several types of potential health effects that could result from the insertion of a novel gene into an organism. In regards to genetic modifications in the food industry, health effects of primary concern to safety are production of new allergens, increased toxicity, decreased nutrition, and antibiotic resistance. By modifying genes to produce desirable traits, we may be reducing genetic diversity and increasing risk factors.
ReplyDeleteYou do a good job of making it clear that while Cas9 is a revolutionary system in this field it still has many shortcomings and problems. Just recently more CRISPR systems are being discovered, this is a very active area of research. While Cas9 is no longer viewed as the most effective of CRISPR systems, it was the one that opened up this field of study. The point you bring up about altering humans is still a long way off, however it does a good job of solidifying your point.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteIt's very interesting to see the sheer number of CRISPR articles being published and researched in association with genetic variation and developing organisms. In the matter of months, new systems of CRISPR are being honed and perfected that make the previous systems seem primitive, and this is a testament to the active research being done in this field of study. It's exciting to see the new developments of CRISPR techniques occurring right before our eyes and that is what makes this area of study so dynamic. I'm especially impressed with the ethical question that you raise in regards to putting a 'cost' to developing more 'perfect' human beings. It is something that will have to be addressed in the coming years, with more and more research being completed in the realm of CRISPR techniques.
ReplyDeleteI think you did a wonderful job at explaining the world of CRISPR in a way that is easy for the readers to follow and comprehend. Like Daniel said above, this blog has made it very clear that CRISPR is a revolutionary advancement in science and DNA manipulation but it still has its kinks. For example, the limitation of DNA and gene manipulation to the early stages in development is very interesting but also extremely time sensitive. The possible result of lowered genetic diversity was another intriguing threat to consider from such manipulation. If scientists have already discovered a way to utilize CRISPR in not only DNA, but also RNA I am very excited to see where they can take this protein in the future.
ReplyDeleteI think that CRISPR's are a very cool new technology. I agree that the uses for such a technology are limitless and it is amazing how fast this type of technology is progressing. I wonder if the CRISPR can edit mRNA because if it could do that there would be even more ways that this technology can help get rid of diseases. I would want them to do more work on the CRISPR before they use it in humans because from this article it seems like there is a decent amount of error still and I think they should work that out before using it in humans.
ReplyDelete